Ten CNIL fines against local authorities: the security gaps to fix before your next inspection
France's CNIL has fined ten public bodies over cybersecurity failings. Remote access, contractors, logs: what to check now, in France and in Belgium alike.
On 9 November 2026, the CNIL, France's data protection authority, announced ten penalties against local and regional authorities and a public body. The fines are modest, from €3,000 to €20,000. The list of failings is anything but. It reads like the audit report that many organisations, public or private, could just as well receive, in France or in Belgium.
What the CNIL found
The decisions follow inspections the CNIL carried out under one of its annual inspection themes for 2025: the cybersecurity of local and regional authorities. Several authorities and public bodies were inspected, along with their service providers. Most failings fall under Article 32 of the GDPR, which requires security measures appropriate to the risk:
- poorly protected remote access, including for staff working from home, and administrator accounts without multi-factor authentication;
- service providers, such as software vendors, with permanent access to the network without case-by-case authorisation, or using accounts shared between several people;
- incomplete logging, or logs that nobody reviews in real time or at short intervals, so abnormal behaviour goes unnoticed;
- insufficient network segmentation, which could allow an intrusion to spread from one zone to another;
- servers running operating systems that no longer receive security patches;
- weak passwords, sent to users in clear text or stored without any guarantee of confidentiality.
Several decisions also note that online services for residents went live without the security accreditation ("homologation") that France's General Security Framework (RGS) requires of public administrations. Some authorities had also suffered data breaches that, according to the CNIL, adequate measures could have prevented.
One final failing is not technical: several authorities were also penalised for installing cameras on public roads without a prior data protection impact assessment (DPIA). The CNIL regards such a system as systematic, large-scale monitoring of a publicly accessible area, which requires that assessment (Article 90 of the French Data Protection Act, the loi Informatique et Libertés).
Why these penalties matter
None of these failings stems from an exceptional attack. These are basic measures that have been known and documented for years.
The choice of the simplified procedure points the same way. It is reserved for cases that raise no particular difficulty: the chair of the CNIL's restricted committee, or a member they appoint, decides alone, after a mainly written exchange. According to the CNIL, €20,000 is the legal maximum that applies to these bodies under this type of procedure. The amounts reflect the number and seriousness of the failings, the nature of the data (minors' data, bank details), the body's budget, the number of people affected and the remedial measures already taken.
The CNIL says other proceedings are under way and may lead to penalties, formal notices or reminders of legal obligations. It states that it is devoting half of its inspections and enforcement action in 2026 to data security, and links this work to preparing for NIS2, whose transposition into French law is still ongoing.
And in Belgium?
Article 32 of the GDPR applies in exactly the same way, and the Data Protection Authority (APD/GBA) enforces it. One major difference remains: the Act of 30 July 2018 (Article 221(2)) rules out administrative fines for public authorities, except for public-law bodies that offer goods or services on a market. The Constitutional Court dismissed an action for annulment against this exemption in 2021. On 27 June 2025, however, the Court of Cassation referred a question to the Court of Justice of the European Union on whether it is compatible with the GDPR, in a case concerning a subsidised private school. Above all, no fine does not mean no obligations: the authority can issue a reprimand, order processing to be brought into compliance or restrict it, and anyone who suffers damage can still claim compensation (Article 82 GDPR).
As for NIS2, local authorities are not automatically covered by the Act of 26 April 2024. Some activities, such as water, energy or healthcare, may nonetheless bring a municipality, a public social welfare centre (CPAS/OCMW) or an inter-municipal company within scope: this has to be assessed case by case. For entities in scope, the CyberFundamentals (CyFun) framework of the Centre for Cybersecurity Belgium covers most of the technical points raised by the CNIL.
What to check now
Municipality, welfare centre or SME: the CNIL's list makes a useful self-assessment checklist.
- Access: multi-factor authentication for all remote access and every administrator account, without exception.
- Service providers: named accounts, enabled on request, time-limited and logged; no shared accounts and no permanent access "for maintenance".
- Logs: collect the relevant traces, protect them, keep them for six months to a year as the CNIL recommends, and above all analyse them, with automated alerts or continuous monitoring by a SOC.
- Network: separate, at a minimum, administration, servers, workstations and connected devices such as cameras.
- Obsolete systems: inventory them, plan their replacement and isolate them in the meantime.
- New services: before an online service goes live or cameras are installed, a risk assessment and, where the processing requires it, a DPIA.
Key takeaways
These decisions do not penalise organisations overwhelmed by an exceptional attack, but the absence of basic measures. That is what makes them useful: they show what a data protection authority or a NIS2 auditor is most likely to examine first. Better to check it yourself, with evidence, before you have to justify it.
Cyber Praxis supports public bodies and SMEs, from security and compliance audits to outsourced DPO services.
Sources: CNIL, "Cybersécurité des collectivités territoriales : la CNIL prononce dix sanctions", 9 November 2026 (in French), the simplified sanction procedure (in French) and recommendations on logging (in French); Belgian Constitutional Court, judgment No. 3/2021 of 14 January 2021 (in French); Belgian Court of Cassation, judgment of 27 June 2025, C.24.0186.N (in Dutch); Union des Villes et Communes de Wallonie, note on NIS2 and local authorities, updated in 2026 (in French).